How Do I Know If I Need To Replace My Furnace Or If Repairs Will Suffice?


Are you wondering if it’s time to replace your furnace or if repairs will do the trick? Well, we’ve got you covered! In this article, we’ll help you determine whether your furnace needs a complete replacement or if a few repairs will suffice.

We’ll explore factors such as the age and lifespan of your furnace, the frequency and cost of repairs, inefficiency, and rising energy bills, uneven heating and poor air quality, as well as safety concerns like carbon monoxide leaks.

Let’s get started!

Age and Lifespan of the Furnace

If your furnace is over 15 years old, it’s likely time to consider a replacement rather than repairs. As HVAC experts, we have found that the age and lifespan of a furnace play a crucial role in determining whether repairs are worth it or if it’s better to invest in a new unit.

Over time, furnaces experience wear and tear due to constant usage. Older units tend to be less efficient and may require frequent repairs to keep them running smoothly. Additionally, older furnaces may not meet current energy efficiency standards, resulting in higher utility bills.

When deciding between repairs and replacement, consider the cost-effectiveness of each option. While repairing an older furnace might seem like a more affordable choice upfront, it could end up costing you more in the long run. With advancements in technology, newer models are designed to be more energy-efficient and reliable, saving you money on monthly heating expenses and reducing the likelihood of future breakdowns.

Furthermore, safety is another critical factor when dealing with an aging furnace. Older units are prone to developing issues such as cracks in heat exchangers or malfunctioning components that can lead to carbon monoxide leaks or fires. By replacing your old furnace with a new one, you can ensure the safety of your home and family.

Frequency and Cost of Repairs

You should consider the frequency and cost of repairs before making a decision about your furnace. It’s important to weigh the ongoing expenses and inconvenience of frequent repairs against the potential investment of a new furnace. To help you make an informed decision, let’s take a look at a table comparing the frequency and average cost of common furnace repairs versus the cost of replacing the entire unit.

RepairFrequencyAverage Cost
Igniter ReplacementOnce every 5-7 years$150-$300
Blower Motor ReplacementOnce every 10-15 years$400-$600
Heat Exchanger ReplacementOnce every 15-20 years$1,000-$2,500

As you can see from this table, while certain repairs may be necessary over time, they are typically infrequent and come with varying price tags. However, if your furnace is consistently needing expensive repairs or if it is more than 15-20 years old, it might be worth considering a replacement. Remember to factor in energy efficiency improvements and potential savings on utility bills when evaluating whether it’s time to replace your furnace.

To Schedule Furnace Repair or Replacement Assessment, Reach Out Now:

(647) 972-8714

Inefficiency and Rising Energy Bills

To determine if your furnace is experiencing inefficiency and causing rising energy bills, it’s important to assess its age and performance. Here are five signs that indicate your furnace may be inefficient:

  • Uneven heating: If some rooms in your home feel colder than others, it could be a sign of an inefficient furnace. Hot and cold spots can mean your system is struggling to distribute heat evenly.
  • Increased utility bills: If you notice a sudden spike in your energy bills without any change in usage, it could be due to an inefficient furnace. Older furnaces tend to consume more energy as they struggle to maintain desired temperatures.
  • Constant repairs: If you find yourself calling for repairs frequently, it may indicate that your furnace is inefficient and nearing the end of its lifespan. The cost of constant repairs can quickly add up, making replacement more cost-effective.
  • Noisy operation: A noisy furnace can be a sign of wear and tear or malfunctioning components. Excessive noise could indicate inefficiency as the system works harder than necessary.
  • Age of the furnace: Furnaces typically last between 15 to 20 years. If yours is approaching or exceeding this age range, it’s likely becoming less efficient and may be time for a replacement.

Uneven Heating and Poor Air Quality

Experiencing uneven heating and poor air quality can be indicators of an inefficient furnace.

When we notice that certain rooms in our home are significantly colder or hotter than others, it suggests that our furnace is not distributing heat evenly throughout the house.

  • This can lead to discomfort and frustration as we constantly adjust the thermostat to compensate for these temperature differences.
  • Furthermore, if we find ourselves constantly sneezing or experiencing respiratory issues while indoors, it might be a sign of poor air quality caused by our furnace.
  • An inefficient furnace may not properly filter out dust, allergens, and pollutants from the air, leading to decreased indoor air quality and potential health problems.
  • In addition to these discomforts, an inefficient furnace can also have financial consequences. The constant adjustments to maintain a comfortable temperature can result in higher energy bills. We may find ourselves spending more money on gas or electricity because our furnace is working harder than it should be due to its inefficiency.

To ensure optimal comfort and cost-effectiveness in our homes, it is important to address these signs of an inefficient furnace promptly. Whether through repairs or replacement, taking action will help us enjoy consistent heating and improved air quality throughout our living spaces while saving money on energy bills.

Safety Concerns and Carbon Monoxide Leaks

If left unaddressed, a carbon monoxide leak from an inefficient furnace can pose serious safety concerns. We know that the safety of our homes and families is of utmost importance. That’s why it’s crucial to be aware of the potential dangers associated with a faulty or old furnace.

Here are some key points to keep in mind:

  • Carbon monoxide (CO) is an odourless and colourless gas that can be produced by faulty furnaces.
  • Breathing in high levels of CO can lead to symptoms such as headaches, dizziness, nausea, and even death.
  • Installing a carbon monoxide detector near your furnace is essential for early detection and prevention.
  • Regular maintenance and inspections by professionals can help identify any potential leaks or issues before they become hazardous.
  • If you suspect a carbon monoxide leak or experience any symptoms, evacuate your home immediately and contact emergency services.

Replace Or Repair My Furnace – FAQ

(647) 972-8714

What are the signs that indicate the age and lifespan of a furnace?

Signs that indicate the age and lifespan of a furnace include its energy efficiency, physical condition, and frequent breakdowns. A furnace’s efficiency decreases over time, resulting in higher energy bills.

Additionally, if your furnace is constantly breaking down or requiring repairs, it could be a sign that it has reached the end of its lifespan.

It is essential to consider these factors when determining whether to replace your furnace or opt for repairs.

How much does it typically cost to repair a furnace, and how often do repairs need to be done?

Furnace repair costs and frequency vary depending on the issue and type of furnace. Repairs can range from $50 for a simple fix to $1,500 for major repairs.

Common problems like a faulty thermostat or dirty filters may require regular maintenance every 3-6 months. However, more serious issues like a cracked heat exchanger or motor failure might necessitate immediate attention and costlier repairs.

It’s best to consult with a professional to assess the specific situation

Are there any common reasons for rising energy bills and inefficient heating that are not mentioned in the article?

There may be several common reasons for rising energy bills and inefficient heating that are not mentioned in the article. Some potential causes could include:
– Inadequate insulation
– Air leaks in windows or doors
– Thermostat issues
– Dirty air filters

These factors can put extra strain on your furnace and decrease its efficiency. It’s essential to address these issues alongside any necessary repairs to ensure optimal performance and energy savings.

What are some other possible causes for uneven heating and poor air quality in a home, aside from a faulty furnace?

Other possible causes for uneven heating and poor air quality in a home, aside from a faulty furnace, could include clogged air filters, leaky ductwork, or inadequate insulation. These issues can lead to restricted airflow and inconsistent distribution of heat throughout the house.

Additionally, mould or excessive dust buildup can contribute to poor air quality. It’s important to address these potential causes before considering whether repairs or replacement of the furnace is necessary.

Besides safety concerns and carbon monoxide leaks, are there any other potential dangers or risks associated with a malfunctioning furnace that homeowners should be aware of?

Besides safety concerns and carbon monoxide leaks, there are other potential dangers associated with a malfunctioning furnace that homeowners should be aware of.

A faulty furnace can lead to inadequate heating, which can result in discomfort and health issues during cold weather. Additionally, it may cause increased energy consumption and higher utility bills.

It’s important to regularly check for any signs of malfunctioning and consult a professional for proper maintenance or replacement if necessary.


In conclusion, determining whether to get a new furnace or repair your furnace depends on several factors.

  • Consider the age and lifespan of your furnace, as well as the frequency and cost of repairs.
  • Inefficiency and rising energy bills can also indicate the need for a replacement.
  • Uneven heating and poor air quality should not be ignored, as they can affect your comfort and health.
  • Lastly, safety concerns such as carbon monoxide leaks should be taken seriously.

Consulting with a professional will help you make an informed decision that ensures a warm and safe home.

Furnace Repair/Replace – Consult With Us!

Schedule Furnace Repair or Replacement Assessment At Your Location

ALP Heating is committed to providing the finest service possible to important areas. We are delighted to be your go-to cooling and heating business for all of your requirements. Because of our commitment to perfection.